Lindy Hop is Smooth

Do our readers pay attention to the west coast swing world? We do as a result of our Lindy Hop journey occurring nearly simultaneously with our West Coast Swing journey so we’re cognizant of the attempts to embed this notion of renaming WCS to “Modern Swing.” Folks are always trying to create differentiators with their marketing terms to set themselves apart but there can be this feeling of Othering at times especially when you realize that Black contributions and kinesthetic values are potentially being whitewashed. Here are some of our thoughts as conveyed in response today’s discourse:

Here's a good article about the Savoy vs Hollywood style debates - https://swungover.wordpress.com/2011/06/15/savoy-style-vs-hollywood-style-a-fight-to-the-death-hopefully/.

One point to make is that Hollywood style was pure marketing that also referred to itself as "smooth" in order to contrast it with Savoy. This echoes how Skippy Blair utilized language to create differentiation between swing dance styles. Now look at this old school Lindy Hopper, George Lloyd - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xqMiAIkCyIE The man was smooth and glided along the floor. This is just one of a myriad of examples, but Lindy Hop as born out of the Savoy Ballroom in Harlem was smooth. This echoes one of vernacular dances' values - the aesthetic of cool. Even Frankie Manning taught and spoken out about Lindy Hop being smooth.

One of the key differences too is that Black Lindy Hoppers mostly danced fast, athletic, showcasing airsteps in a lot of movies. White lindy hoppers got to do a lot of social dancing and frame their dancing in such a way for the camera, i.e. slotted.

It's fine to acknowledge regional differences but we need to be wary when we're echoing talking points that Other Blackness.

And labeling or attempting to rename WCS as "Modern Swing" seemingly ignores all the swing dances happening now in various regions of the country. We're all modern people living in a modern age bringing our modernness to bear on the dances we dance. It's kind of silly.